Sparking the Opportunity Revolution. Is Devolution the Solution?

Our top Devolutionista, Devo Agency's Creator and Founder, Gill Morris gives her take on what Milburn’s opportunity revolution means for good growth.

Image credit: Simon Dawson/No 10 Downing Street

Can Milburn rewire welfare, close the capacity and opportunity gaps, and are Mayors ready?

We don't just have a NEET problem. We have a failure to connect people with opportunity. And no amount of welfare reform will fix that unless we also fix the opportunity infrastructure – from schools and colleges to transport, employers and the Jobcentre itself.

The real litmus test for the Milburn Review won’t be how many young people we move off benefits into learning and earning. It will be how many we move into opportunity, how many employers we motivate to invest in their future workforce, and whether Mayors have the powers, money and capacity to make it happen.

At the heart of the Milburn Review is a question that goes far beyond welfare reform: are we prepared to change the way the State works so that young people don’t become disconnected from the economy in the first place? 

Circa one million+ people are not in education, employment or training, and yet employers still say they can’t access the skills they need and fill vacancies. That mismatch requires more than a tweak to our welfare system to fix it.

Milburn’s answer is to move away from a welfare state to a working state: from managing economic inactivity to creating opportunity, and from intervention after failure to prevention.That raises three big questions. Can Milburn rewire welfare? Can devolution deliver an opportunity revolution? And are Mayors ready?

Why devolution is the missing piece

For far too long, tackling the youth unemployment crisis has been driven by fragmented services, disconnected budgets and weak accountability for outcomes. That can’t be right and we can’t put it right with another centrally designed programme using the same fragmented structures.

Mayoral combined and strategic authorities are best placed to know what local economies need. They have skin in the game. They know where the jobs and skills gaps are and the communities that are failing. They have the freedom to do things differently. They have the power to drive economic development, investment and innovation in a way that Whitehall can’t.

What’s required is more than asking Mayors to coordinate a few existing programmes. It requires genuine powers, flexible funding and the capacity to commission and deliver integrated support. Devolution -done well - has great potential to create opportunities and prevent failure.

Closing the capacity gap: are Mayors ready?

We have spent years talking about devolving powers to Mayors, but have we spent enough time thinking about their capacity to deliver?

The Milburn Review proposes Mayors and strategic authorities lead local Youth Opportunity Services, backed by multi-year Participation Agreements, with a service in every area by 2029. That is a significant shift in responsibility, and it can’t be delivered by adding another programme to an already crowded portfolio. To make it work, Mayors need to be able to bring together:

● DWP employment and welfare support

● Schools, colleges, independent training providers and careers services

● NHS and local authority health services

● Youth services and voluntary and community organisations

● Employers, business organisations and anchor institutions

● Housing, transport and wider support that enables participation

They also need the data to identify young people at risk, the staff to support them and the funding to intervene early. There is a gap between the ambition of devolution and what many strategic authorities can currently deliver. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has warned that Milburn’s proposals will need significant additional public spending and new local delivery capacity, which can’t be achieved on goodwill alone.

If the Government wants Mayors to be accountable for outcomes, it must give them the tools, powers and resources to influence them, and resist devolving responsibility without the means to deliver.

Opportunity without access isn’t opportunity

Even with the right structures in place, there is a further question: can young people actually reach the opportunities on offer? A college place isn’t an opportunity if the course is full. A job isn’t one if there’s no affordable bus to get there. An apprenticeship isn’t one if the wages barely cover the travel.

On education, Milburn identifies around 32,000 unfunded further education students, along with funding rules that penalise colleges when students don’t complete, which makes flexible provision for those most at risk harder to offer. Prevention also has to start earlier, in primary and secondary schools, without simply landing on headteachers who are already stretched. Independent training providers, adult education and employer-led provision all have a part to play too.

Then there’s travel and cost. Greater Manchester has shown how free bus travel for young people removes barriers to opportunity.  But the barriers don’t end there. For young people from low-income households, a first job brings real costs: transport, clothing, equipment, lunches, childcare and the loss of some household support. A support guarantee should include practical help with these costs, not just advice and referrals.

Will employers invest – or will we simply ask them to do more?

This is perhaps the biggest test of all.

We can redesign welfare, join up public services and devolve employment support. But unless employers are prepared to invest in young people, we will still have a missing link. Employers often say they cannot find people with the right skills. Yet young people are told they need experience to get a job, while employers are reluctant to invest in someone who doesn’t already have it.

We need to break that cycle.

Milburn recognises this and proposes a more substantial package of employer incentives. These include a £3,000 payment for employers taking on a young person who has been NEET for six months, with additional premiums for those facing greater barriers and for smaller businesses. He also proposes increased apprenticeship incentives and a gradual reduction in employer National Insurance costs for under-25s, initially focused on sectors such as retail and hospitality, when fiscal conditions allow.

Importantly, he proposes that Government should monitor the cumulative cost of employment policies through a Youth Employment Cost Index. This is a welcome recognition that employment costs matter.

There is a difficult tension here. Increases in the National Minimum Wage and employer National Insurance costs have increased the cost of employing people, while the convergence of youth wage rates reduces some of the financial distinction between employing an inexperienced young person and a more experienced worker. That does not mean young people should be paid less or that decent wages are the problem. But it does mean we need to be realistic about the economics of recruitment and training, particularly for SMEs.

The Government needs to look at the combined impact of wage policy, National Insurance, employment regulation and training costs on the willingness and ability of businesses to create entry-level opportunities. Milburn’s proposed Youth Employment Cost Index is therefore important. We need evidence, not assumptions, about what is helping or hindering employers.

We need a much stronger compact between government and employers. That means:

● Wage subsidies and meaningful incentives for taking on young people.

● Funding for training and qualifications, not just recruitment.

● More flexible apprenticeship models, including introductory pathways and progression into full apprenticeships.

● Better use of the Growth and Skills Levy to support young people entering the workforce.

● Paid work placements and meaningful work experience.

● A stronger role for anchor institutions and public procurement in creating entry-level opportunities.

● Support for employers to recruit and retain disabled young people and those with additional needs.

And we need to make it easier for businesses to participate. One front door, less bureaucracy and a clear offer of support. The prize is not simply getting young people into jobs. It is building a workforce fit for the future.

Prevention is better than cure – but will the system actually change?

This is perhaps the most important.

One of the biggest mistakes we make is waiting until a young person has failed before we intervene.

By the time someone is 18, has left school without qualifications, lost confidence, become disconnected from education and is struggling to find work, the cost of putting things right is considerably greater.

Failure rarely happens overnight

It can start in primary school with poor attendance or unmet learning needs. It can develop through secondary education when a young person becomes disengaged, struggles with mental health or cannot see a pathway that works for them. It can become entrenched at 16 or 18 when the transition into further education, training or work breaks down.

And once someone is outside the system, it can be incredibly difficult to reconnect them.

Milburn is right to put prevention at the heart of his proposals. But prevention must not become another responsibility that is passed between institutions without anyone being accountable for the outcome.

Schools, colleges, local authorities, health services and employers all have a role. Mayors could provide the strategic leadership to bring them together, with a clear expectation that no young person is allowed to disappear between services.

And we need to measure success differently.

Not simply how many young people have been referred, how many appointments have been attended or how many people are no longer on benefits. We should measure sustained participation, qualifications gained, progression into work, earnings, confidence and improved life chances.

The ambition must be to prevent failure, not simply become better at managing it.

The real test: can Mayors deliver the opportunity revolution?

There is much to welcome in the Milburn Review. It is ambitious, recognises the systemic nature of the problem and makes a strong case for locally led solutions. It could also be one of the most important tests yet for English devolution. It places the spotlight on Mayoral capability. Can they deliver the opportunities, move beyond economic development and drive a much broader agenda for economic and social change in every postcode?

If we have been here before what’s the difference this time? Governments have launched youth guarantees, employment programmes and skills initiatives aplenty. The problem has never been a shortage of announcements. Rather a lack of continuity, fragmented funding, short-termism and weak accountability for outcomes.

If we are serious about rewiring government, we need to organise public services around people and places rather than departmental boundaries. That means Mayors working with councils, schools, colleges, employers, the NHS and communities to make sure people stop falling through the cracks.

It means recognising that economic growth and social inclusion are interdependent, and that skills, health, housing, transport and employment are all part of the same equation.

There is a real opportunity revolution in our grasp. An opportunity to connect the Milburn agenda to the wider devolution settlement, using integrated funding, local leadership and stronger partnerships to deliver what Whitehall has to date struggled to achieve.

This is a 10 year plan fit for the future and one which must deliver opportunities to work which are  felt in every postcode. This time it will be different!

Next
Next

Beyond the Numbers: How Local Government Can Fix the Housing Delivery Engine